How Do You Investigate Reportable Conduct Allegations From 20 or 30 Years Ago?

Investigator reviewing archived institutional records as part of a historical reportable conduct investigation.

Historical allegations, the National Redress Scheme and the challenges of conducting a fair investigation.

An organisation receives information alleging that one of its employees sexually abused a child more than 25 years ago. The alleged victim is now an adult, the employee denies the allegation, and there may be few records or witnesses available.

The allegation may have come to light through an application to the National Redress Scheme (NRS), a civil claim, or a disclosure made directly to the organisation.

What should the organisation do? Is it required to investigate an allegation from decades ago? What happens if the alleged victim does not wish to participate? And how can the organisation reach a fair finding when the evidence is incomplete?

These questions are addressed in guidance published by the NSW Office of the Children's Guardian in October 2025. Although the guidance relates specifically to the NSW Reportable Conduct Scheme, many of the investigation principles are relevant to organisations across Australia.

1. Does the organisation have to investigate an allegation from decades ago?

The first question is whether the allegation falls within the reportable conduct legislation applicable to the organisation.

In NSW, historical allegations involving current employees may trigger reporting and investigation obligations, even where the alleged conduct occurred decades earlier. There is no prescribed period after which an allegation becomes too old to fall within the NSW Reportable Conduct Scheme.

Where the person is no longer employed by the organisation, the position may be different. However, the organisation should still consider whether the information raises current child protection concerns or requires referral to another authority.

Reporting obligations and the treatment of former employees vary between jurisdictions, so organisations should check the relevant legislation and regulator's guidance.

2. What happens when the allegation comes through the National Redress Scheme?

The National Redress Scheme provides eligible survivors of institutional child sexual abuse with an opportunity to seek redress.

An organisation may first become aware of a historical allegation when it receives information concerning an application involving one of its current employees.

This creates particular challenges.

An applicant may not wish to participate in a separate reportable conduct investigation. They may have already provided a detailed account of their experiences and may be reluctant to revisit those events.

There are also legal restrictions on the use and disclosure of information obtained through the NRS.

The National Redress Scheme for Institutional Child Sexual Abuse Act 2018 (Cth) contains provisions protecting information obtained for the purposes of the scheme. Organisations need to understand these restrictions before using or disclosing NRS information, including when considering sharing information with another employer or institution.

Importantly, an application to the NRS does not establish that the alleged conduct occurred. An investigation must independently assess the evidence before reaching findings.

3. Can the investigator contact the alleged victim?

This is one of the most important practical considerations.

An investigator will generally want to obtain an account from the alleged victim. However, a historical allegation may involve someone who has already described their experience during an NRS application, civil proceedings or a police investigation.

Any approach should be trauma-informed and respectful of the person's wishes.

Where the person is legally represented, the investigator should ordinarily communicate through their legal representative.

Where the allegation arises through the NRS, restrictions on the use and disclosure of information must also be considered. The NSW regulator's guidance outlines a process for inviting participation through the NRS secure portal.

Investigators should explain why the investigation is being undertaken, what participation would involve and how the information provided may be used.

The alleged victim should have sufficient time to consider whether they wish to participate.

4. What if the alleged victim refuses to participate?

An alleged victim's unwillingness to participate does not necessarily prevent an investigation from proceeding.

There may be understandable reasons why someone does not wish to revisit events that occurred decades earlier.

Investigators should make reasonable efforts to invite participation but should respect a person's decision not to engage.

Where the person declines to participate, the investigator should consider what other evidence may be available.

This might include contemporaneous documents, previous complaints, historical employment records, statements provided in other proceedings where lawfully available, and evidence from former employees or other witnesses.

The investigator must then consider whether the available evidence is sufficient to reach a finding.

In some circumstances, there may be insufficient information to conduct a meaningful investigation. Depending on the applicable legislation, it may be appropriate to discuss the matter with the relevant regulator and consider whether any exemption or alternative process is available.

5. How do you investigate allegations when the evidence is decades old?

Historical investigations present obvious evidentiary difficulties.

Witnesses may have died or become difficult to locate. Employment records may have been destroyed, and policies operating at the time may no longer be available.

Recollections may also be incomplete.

For example, an alleged victim might identify an incident as occurring in 1995, but employment records establish that the employee commenced working at the institution in 1996.

Does that inconsistency mean the allegation is false?

Not necessarily.

The investigator should examine the discrepancy and consider whether it may be explained by the passage of time.

Other evidence may assist in establishing when the parties were at the institution, whether they had contact with one another and whether the alleged circumstances were possible.

An investigator should also consider alternative explanations and evidence that contradicts the allegation.

The passage of time may affect the reliability of evidence, but it does not mean that historical allegations cannot be substantiated.

6. Should the employee be suspended while the investigation is underway?

Some organisations automatically suspend employees when historical sexual abuse allegations emerge, particularly where a National Redress Scheme application or civil claim is involved.

However, automatic suspension is not necessarily required.

The organisation should undertake a risk assessment based on the available information.

Relevant considerations may include:

  • The seriousness and nature of the allegation.

  • The employee's current duties and contact with children.

  • Whether previous child protection concerns have been raised.

  • The time that has elapsed since the alleged conduct.

  • Whether supervision, alternative duties or other arrangements can adequately manage identified risks.

  • Any relevant police advice.

The NSW regulator's guidance specifically recognises that the passage of time, particularly in the absence of subsequent concerns, may be relevant to determining whether an employee needs to be stood down.

However, the protection of children remains the primary consideration.

Any decision to suspend an employee, restrict their duties or allow them to continue working should be supported by a documented risk assessment and reviewed as further evidence becomes available.

7. Does the investigation have to wait until the National Redress Scheme application is finalised?

Not necessarily.

An NRS application or civil claim does not automatically prevent an organisation from conducting its own investigation.

The relevant regulator may expect the organisation to progress the investigation where appropriate, particularly if there are current risks to children.

However, police involvement requires separate consideration.

Where an allegation may constitute a criminal offence, organisations should promptly consider their reporting obligations and coordinate with police before taking investigative steps that might prejudice a criminal investigation.

In NSW, the regulator's guidance requires an organisation that has reported a matter to police to place its investigation on hold until police provide clearance.

Organisations operating in other jurisdictions should follow the requirements and guidance applicable to them.

8. What if there is insufficient evidence to make a finding?

Historical allegations sometimes cannot be resolved because important evidence is unavailable.

An investigator may have an account of alleged abuse but no opportunity to clarify it, interview the alleged victim or obtain sufficient additional evidence.

The investigator should assess the evidence that is available and determine whether it supports a finding on the applicable standard of proof.

Where the evidence is insufficient, the report should explain the inquiries undertaken, the evidence that could not be obtained and the reasons for the finding.

An inability to substantiate an allegation does not necessarily establish that the alleged conduct did not occur.

Clear reasons are particularly important in historical matters because the absence of evidence may result from the passage of time rather than any deficiency in the original complaint.

Final thoughts

Historical reportable conduct investigations require careful planning and sensitivity.

Organisations need to consider the wishes and wellbeing of alleged victims, the rights of employees, restrictions applying to National Redress Scheme information and any ongoing risk to children.

They also need to understand their obligations under the reportable conduct legislation applicable in their jurisdiction.

Although the NSW regulator has published particularly detailed guidance on historical allegations, the practical issues it identifies are relevant to investigators and organisations throughout Australia.

A well-conducted investigation should pursue reasonable lines of inquiry, assess the evidence fairly and provide clear reasons for its findings.

References

  • NSW Office of the Children's Guardian, Fact Sheet 14 – Handling Historical Reportable Allegations (October 2025).

  • National Redress Scheme for Institutional Child Sexual Abuse Act 2018 (Cth).

  • Relevant state or territory reportable conduct legislation and regulator guidance.

Next
Next

When Should You Tell an Employee About a Reportable Conduct Allegation?